This post contains affiliate links.
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through these links.

You’ve booked your Disney cruise, you’ve joined the social media group for your sail date, and now you’ve signed up for this thing called a Fish Extender Exchange. Now you’re wondering what on earth do I actually get as gifts for this exchange, right? We’ve been a part of a few exchanges on our past cruises. We’ve done a combination of purchased items and handmade items, and received a variety of both as well. I was browsing Etsy recently for Disney related things and came upon some great ideas for Fish Extender gifts! And then I started searching for more. There were so many fun and beautiful things to choose from that I just had to share a few of my favourites with you!  


Kacey from CheekyMonkeySupplyCo has a really neat collection of gift ideas in her shop. There are earrings, hair clips, storage cases, key rings and more! Definitely check out what else she has available by clicking HERE.


Matt from GreyOwlDesign creates the most beautiful wooden Disney magnets I’ve ever seen! I think my favourites are the Disney Cruise logo and the ship designs. See more of his creations by clicking HERE.


Dee from PrincessandMain makes these super cute wish bracelets! They are so dainty and elegant looking. I really love her simple Mickey head design! Have a look at her wish bracelets by clicking HERE.


CreationNationGifts is a mother/daughter pair that put together these super cute tic-tac-toe tins. They also have tins themed with Olaf and Anna & Elsa! Check out these adorable tins by clicking HERE.


Diana from PixieDustedStitches has so many neat creations to choose from. Items range from nautical bracelets and mini flashlights to “yacht-sea” games and wristlet keychains!  Click HERE to see even more of Diana’s items!


Alex from Canterbury1Creations has a few different designs for can coolers available. I think my favourite would be the anchor design with the cruise year printed on it. These would make a fun gift for holding any kind of canned drink, whether an adult beverage or an everyday soda pop. Check out the other designs by clicking HERE.

So which gift idea above would be your favourite to give or receive? Let me know in the comments below!